Is vitamin K3 toxic?

The conclusion in brief

Nej. De nyreskader, der er beskrevet hos heste, opstod ved K3-injektioner på omkring 5.000 mg, cirka 1.000 gange mere end en dagsdosis i foder. Every Day Happy og Peak Performance giver 10‑11 mg K3 til en 500 kg hest. Kritikken af folinsyre stammer fra humane studier ved meget høje doser.

Vitamin K: An important vitamin family

Vitamin K is a group of related substances that are best known for being important for the blood's ability to clot, i.e. to stop bleeding from wounds, injuries, and operations. Recent research has shown that vitamin K is of great importance for a wide range of processes in various tissues:

  • The liver and coagulation factors
  • Connective tissue (Matrix Gla protein), cartilage, blood vessels, circulation and skin
  • Calcium metabolism and bone development , i.e. inhibition of calcification in soft tissue and incorporation of calcium into the bones, including bone development in foals/young horses and wound healing
  • Blood sugar regulation, muscle function and cellular stability (microtubules)

The three forms of vitamin K

Vitamin K exists in three forms, each with its own origin:

  • Vitamin K1 (phylloquinone) : Found in green plants, including grass. Absorbed in the small intestine and has a short storage in the liver.
  • Vitamin K2 (menaquinone) : Produced by intestinal bacteria and absorbed from the small intestine. Foals ingest this through their mother's feces to get the right bacteria.
  • Vitamin K3 (menadione) : A synthetic product that is absorbed in both the small intestine and the large intestine.

The need for vitamin K in complementary foods

Phylloquinone (K1) is normally provided by fresh grass. However, many horses have limited access to grass and may therefore need vitamin K supplementation. Furthermore, hay loses around 70% of its vitamin K content during drying. This means that vitamin K is important in supplementary feed for:

  • Winter feeding with wrap and hay
  • Summer feeding for horses without sufficient access to fresh grass
  • Horses with special needs such as ulcers, weight loss programs or injuries
  • Young horses and breeding horses

Vitamin K safety and dosage in Every Day Happy and Peak Performance

Horses can consume large amounts of K1 through grass and alfalfa without any problems. In the past, K3 was given in large doses as injections, which in rare cases led to kidney damage in horses. The dosage in these problematic cases was about 5 grams (5000 mg/horse), which is 1000 times higher than the recommended doses.

Every Day Happy and Peak Performance contain 21 mg K3 per kg of feed. At a daily dosage of 100 grams/100 kg of body weight, a horse thus receives only 2.1 mg/100 kg of body weight, corresponding to 10-11 mg/500 kg of horse. These doses are well documented for their safety and effectiveness and are efficiently converted to K2 without the risk of organ strain.

Scientific sources

Read more in the following references:

  • Scientific Opinion on the safety and efficacy of vitamin K3 (menadione sodium bisulphite and menadione nicotinamide bisulphite) as a feed additive for all animal species
  • Vitamin K: history, metabolism, and nutrition in the horse
  • Rebhun WC, Tennant BC, Dill SG, King JM. Vitamin K3-induced renal toxicosis in the horse . J Am Vet Med Assoc. 1984.
  • Terachi T, Inoue Y, Ashihara N, Kobayashi M, Ando K, Matsui T. Plasma vitamin K concentration in horses supplemented with several vitamin K analogs . J. Anim. Sci.

Ofte stillede spørgsmål om K3-vitamin og folinsyre

Bør man vælge et tilskud uden K3?

Der er ikke fagligt belæg for at fravælge K3 i de mængder, der bruges i foder. Vælger du et produkt uden K-vitamin, skal du til gengæld være opmærksom på dækningen om vinteren, hvor hø har mistet det meste af sit K1.

Er methylfolat bedre end folinsyre til heste?

Der er ingen dokumentation for det hos heste. Begge former omdannes til den aktive form i kroppen, og folinsyre har den praktiske fordel, at den er stabil og kan doseres præcist.

Hvorfor bruges syntetiske vitaminformer i foder?

Fordi de naturlige former svinger i indhold og nedbrydes under lagring og forarbejdning. Så ville du ikke vide, hvad hesten faktisk fik, og det er hele pointen med et tilskud.

Kan hesten få for meget K-vitamin fra græs?

Heste kan indtage store mængder K1 gennem græs og lucerne uden problemer. Det er ikke dér, risikoen har ligget.